There is something incredibly exciting about discovering a new musical in a small theatre space before it potentially grows into something much bigger, and Dark of the Moon feels like exactly that kind of production.

Based on the 1940s play by Howard Richardson and William Berney, this new musical adaptation brings a timeless story of forbidden love, prejudice and belonging to the stage for the first time as a musical. Described as Romeo and Juliet meets Twilight meets Harry Potter, it is a supernatural love story set between two very different worlds: the people of a rural Appalachian town and the mysterious conjure folk who live in the mountains above them.

At the heart of the story are Barbara Allen, a young woman from the town, and John, a witch boy who falls deeply in love with her and longs to become human so they can have a life together. But their relationship is tested when the truth about John’s identity is revealed, exposing the fear, prejudice and cruelty that can come when people are faced with something they don’t understand.

The biggest strength of this production is undoubtedly its cast. From the moment the first notes are sung, it is clear that this is an ensemble full of exceptional vocal talent. There genuinely wasn’t a weak link in the cast, with every performer bringing incredible power and emotion to their roles.

Glenn Adamson as John is absolutely captivating. His performance carries so much vulnerability, passion and intensity, and his vocals are nothing short of phenomenal. Alongside him, Lauren Jones delivers a beautiful performance as Barbara Allen, and the chemistry between the two leads is one of the production’s greatest achievements. Their connection feels completely believable, which is essential for a story built around a love that defies the expectations of both their worlds. Highlight for me was their duet on 'Wildflower' - absolutely flawless and a beautiful song. Sure to be a future musical theatre classic. 

The musical itself makes some really interesting choices with its score. The contrast between the two communities is reflected brilliantly through the music: the townsfolk are represented through country and bluegrass influences, while the conjure folk bring a much darker rock sound. It creates a clear divide between what the characters perceive as “good” and “evil”, while also challenging the audience to question whether that distinction is really as simple as they believe.

Despite being staged in a relatively small off-West End theatre, the production never feels limited. The simplicity of the staging actually works in its favour, allowing the performances, music and atmosphere to take centre stage. The lighting design is particularly effective, helping to create a world that feels both magical and haunting without needing elaborate scenery.

If I had one small criticism, it would be that some of the lyrics didn’t always reach the same heights as the performances delivering them. As someone who perhaps listens more closely to lyrics in a musical than the average audience member, there were moments where some of the songwriting felt a little straightforward and where certain emotions could have been expressed in a more impactful way. That said, this was far less noticeable in the second half, which felt much stronger lyrically and emotionally, building beautifully towards its conclusion.

Ultimately, Dark of the Moon is a production that feels full of potential. It has a brilliant concept, an outstanding cast and a score that creates a genuinely unique atmosphere. Seeing it in such an intimate venue makes you wonder what this show could become with a larger stage, a bigger budget and the opportunity to expand even further.

There is something special about seeing a musical at this stage of its journey, and I’m genuinely excited to see where Dark of the Moon goes next. If this is the beginning of its story, I suspect we may not have seen the last of it.

Dark of the Moon shows at Charing Cross Theatre London untill 8th August - Find more details here https://darkofthemoonmusical.co.uk/

Hear more about what we thought on Musicals and Monologues every Sunday 9-10pm